Customer Testimonials

See More >

The cake was AMAZING! It was so beautiful and yummy as well. Maddie adored it and everyone thought it was the best cake they'd seen! Thank you for making it so special for her 2nd...


Hi Lindsey,
I'm sorry I wasn't able to meet you but I just wanted to say our anniversary cake was a big hit. It was just gorgeous and I could not have been happier. Thank you. I will def...


Behind The Cakes

Edible Works of Art

Here at Peace of Cakes, we follow the philosophy “Enrich the Senses, Delight the Soul”. The cakes may look fabulous, but are first & foremost a dessert- so taste is king! Feast first with your eyes, then dive in & devour our delicious creations. The secret recipe for Grandma’s Old-Fashion Buttercream puts our cakes above the rest in flavor, hands down.

Lindsey and Erika deliver a stunning cake

Our Dedicated Staff

The Peace of Cakes staff is comprised of three hard-working artists & bakers. 

Lindsey - Founder/Baker/Decorator

Our humble operation was founded in 2008 by Lindsey Mills, owner/baker/decorator. After earning her BFA in sculpture from the Savannah College of Art & Design, Lindsey was trained in pastry arts at famed bakeries Savannah Rum Runner’s & Bodi’s Sophisticated Palate. She came home to Jersey with the dream of opening her own shop to create edible art & spread her love of sugar. Today she manages Peace of Cakes and works meticulously with each client to ensure the very best product.

“I used to be a clay artist, but now sugar has become by favorite medium. Because really, what’s better than art you can eat?”

Erika - Sculptor/Decorator

When Lindsey started the business out of her mom’s kitchen, she recruited fellow sculpture artist Erika (aka Rik) Palmaffy as her right-hand-woman. Erika also holds a BFA in ceramic arts from Montclair State, her passion for clay led her to decorate cookies & ice cream cakes and eventually to Peace of Cakes. 

Dave - Shop Manager

If Lindsey is in the kitchen & Rik is busy sculpting, our shop manager David Cifelli handles orders. He will happily talk cake for hours if you let him! Dave started his Peace of Cakes career as the delivery driver, but with his background in culinary arts he quickly became more than just a very careful delivery man!

As seen on Style Network's The Glam Fairy!